Let’s talk

Design Best Practice

Why we start an identity with a concept, not a logo

Sam Hill
·
·
5
MIN READ
Two bars comparing the two concepts we show with the five concepts we avoid showing

We start an identity with a concept and a story, not a logo or a typeface. A concept shows the client the whole brand at once: the idea, the world it lives in, how it sounds, and how it looks on the things they sell. Decisions come faster, and the design work that follows is explored with the client already on board.

We start an identity with a concept and a story, not a logo or a typeface. A concept shows the client the whole brand at once: the idea, the world it lives in, how it sounds, and how it looks on the things they sell. Decisions come faster, and the design work that follows is explored with the client already on board.

This is a craft opinion, and it is also how we run every project, from a two-week sprint to a research-led rebrand.

Why not start with the logo or the type?

Because a logo is a signature and a typeface is a voice. Neither is the thing being said. Shown on their own early in a project, they invite opinions about the part instead of the whole. The conversation becomes “I’m not sure about that blue” when it should be “that’s us”.

A concept gives every later decision something to be judged against. When a client has agreed on the idea and the world it lives in, a logo option is right or wrong for a reason everyone can name. Without that, every presentation reopens the brief.

What is in a concept?

Everything the client needs to see to make a decision. Not a mood board of other people’s work, which shows taste, but a first version of their own brand, which shows a direction. Ours contain:

  • The idea in one sentence, and the story behind it: where it comes from, what it means for the business and for the customer.
  • The world: imagery, texture and tone, edited down until nothing in it is there by accident.
  • First expressions of the logo direction, type and colour, so the idea has a face.
  • The idea applied to the client’s real things: their product, their shopfront, their homepage, their packaging, their social feed. Mock-ups of what they actually sell, not generic stationery.
  • The words: a line or two in the brand’s voice, so people can hear it as well as see it.

Two concepts, each complete enough that a founder can picture the business living inside it. Not five, because five concepts means we have not decided anything yet.

Two concepts, not five
Two bars comparing the two concepts we show with the five concepts we avoid showing.

How does this run in a sprint?

Before kickoff we build three or four direction zones from the brief and the three brands the client admires. The kickoff on day one is half about the business and half about those zones, so by the end of the hour we know what landed and what did not.

On day three we present the two concepts, live, and the client chooses on the call. By day five the decision is written down in a short note they can share internally. From there the design team explores inside the chosen concept: refining the mark, setting the type system, building the applications. Every option is judged against an idea the client has already said yes to.

Concept timeline inside a sprint
Four steps from direction zones before kickoff to a written decision by day five.

Why does it create momentum?

Nobody gets excited about a colour chip. People get excited about seeing their own shop, their own product and their own homepage in a world that feels right. That excitement is practical. Feedback comes back the same day. Rounds of changes shrink. Design by committee stops, because the committee has already agreed on the idea and now has a shared way to judge the details.

It also protects the design team. Exploring inside a concept with the client on board means a bold option gets a fair hearing. Exploring without one means the safest option wins, because safety is the only thing a room can agree on when it has no idea to agree on.

What goes wrong when you skip it?

Logo first is the common failure: the mark is drawn alone, approved alone and loved alone, then type and colour are chosen to fit it, and the compromises start. Type first, which we have argued for before, is better, because type appears on every surface a brand touches (Typography Is the Hero Image Now). It is still a part before the whole.

The craft questions do not go away. The type system still has to work at small sizes on a price and a legal line, the licence still has to cover web, apps and email, and the mark still has to hold up at favicon size. They come second, inside a concept, so they are solved once instead of renegotiated every round. A concept also makes it easier to build the kind of modular identity system where type, colour and layout work as a set, and to know which assets people will remember (the Distinctive Brand Assets Test).

Concept first against logo first
Two panels comparing concept-first work with logo-first work, four points each.

Does it cost more?

No. It changes the order of work, not the scope. Our Brand Strategy + Brand Design Sprint is $25k for two weeks and runs exactly this way. A research-led strategic rebrand is $25k–$75k, a brand refresh starts at $15k, and all prices exclude GST. See our work for how concepts turned into identities.

FAQ

What is the difference between a concept and a mood board?

A mood board collects other people’s work to show a feeling. A concept is a first version of your own brand: an idea, a story, a world and the idea applied to your real products and pages. You can choose a concept. You can only react to a mood board.

How many concepts do you show?

Two. Each is complete enough to picture the business living inside it, and different enough from the other that the choice means something.

Can we bring our own concept?

Yes, and it often speeds things up. We test it against the business and the competitor set before kickoff, and tell you straight if it holds.

Does the concept change once design starts?

The idea holds. The expression of it sharpens as the logo, type and colour are refined and applied, which is the point of deciding the idea first.